14 Ninja Creami Recipes: Unlock the Full Potential of Your Frozen Treats

Masthead Image
A chocolate Ninja Creami recipe.
Author Name: Beth Rush
Date: Monday November 24, 2025

Body + Mind is reader-supported. We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through some of the links on our site. 


If you’ve recently discovered the Ninja Creami, you already know it’s a game-changer for homemade frozen desserts. From rich ice creams to light sorbets, it’s designed to transform simple ingredients into creamy, flavorful treats. Here are some of the best Ninja Creami recipes to transform your sweet treat game.

1. Protein Ice Cream

      This is the recipe that started it all. Take your favorite protein shake or powder, mix it with milk and freeze it overnight. When you process it in the Ninja Creami, the texture becomes thick and smooth, like real ice cream.

      It’s perfect for anyone who wants to satisfy a sweet craving without losing track of their fitness goals. Vanilla, chocolate, salted caramel, and cookies and cream are the most popular flavors, but you can experiment with almost any protein powder you like.

      2. Strawberry Cheesecake Creami

        This one tastes like dessert from a cafe, only lighter. Blending cottage cheese or Greek yogurt with strawberries and a hint of maple syrup creates a creamy, tangy base that the Ninja Creami transforms into a rich, frozen cheesecake texture. The strawberries add natural sweetness, while the dairy gives it protein and a smooth consistency. It feels indulgent yet refreshing, and it’s easy to adjust the sweetness to suit your taste.

        3. Coffee Creami

          This is for the people who love their morning coffee and want to keep it going through dessert. Cold brew or espresso mixed with milk and a touch of vanilla turns into a rich, frozen latte once processed. The flavor is deep and satisfying, and the texture comes out silky without feeling heavy. It’s a great mid-afternoon pick-me-up or post-dinner treat if you use decaf. While coffee already makes you alert, adding some protein powder can help you sustain your energy levels and keep you fuller for longer. 

          Protein powder to add to Ninja Creami recipes.

          4. Chocolate Banana “Nice Cream”

          Bananas are the secret weapon in this one. When blended and frozen, they create a naturally sweet and creamy base. Add cocoa powder or chocolate protein powder and the Ninja Creami turns it into something that tastes like soft chocolate ice cream. It’s dairy-free, low in added sugar and surprisingly filling. You can even add a spoonful of nut butter to make it richer and more satisfying. 

          5. Vanilla Chai Protein Dessert

            If you like warm spices, this one’s a must-try. Combine vanilla protein powder with a bit of chai concentrate or a sprinkle of cinnamon and nutmeg before freezing. Once it’s spun, it has the same cozy flavor as a chai latte but in frozen form. The subtle spice blends perfectly with the creamy texture, and it feels comforting and energizing at the same time. 

            6. Blueberry Coconut Sorbet

              This one’s light and refreshing. Blueberries blended with coconut milk and a small amount of honey or agave turn into a smooth, tropical sorbet that’s naturally dairy-free. The Creami brings out the fruit’s vibrant color and locks in the fresh flavor. It’s the kind of Ninja Creami recipe that looks fancy but only takes a few minutes of prep. 

              7. Peanut Butter Protein Ice Cream

                If you’re a peanut butter fan, this one’s unbeatable. Mixing milk, a scoop of vanilla or chocolate protein powder, and a spoon of peanut butter makes a rich and creamy base that turns perfectly smooth after freezing. It’s packed with protein and has that sweet-salty balance that makes it hard to stop eating.

                Matcha with a whisk.

                8. Matcha Honey Creami

                  Matcha powder adds a subtle earthiness that pairs beautifully with the sweetness of honey and the creaminess of milk or yogurt. The result is smooth and energizing, with a bright green color that’s as pretty as it is tasty. Additionally, matcha is rich in antioxidants and nutrients, including iron and vitamin A, providing a health boost while satisfying your sweet tooth. 

                  9. Oatmeal Cookie Creami

                    This one feels nostalgic. Oat milk, vanilla protein powder and a sprinkle of cinnamon and brown sugar give it that cozy oatmeal cookie flavor. It’s decadent, comforting and the kind of dessert that feels like a hug in a bowl. 

                    10. Mango Lassi Dessert

                      Inspired by the classic Indian drink, this version blends mango chunks, Greek yogurt and a dash of cardamom. Once frozen and processed, it’s sweet, tangy and incredibly smooth. It’s also full of natural vitamins and protein, making it a great option for breakfast or an afternoon snack. Mango is also a great addition to your diet as it boosts your immune system and can ease constipation. 

                      Fresh mango.

                      11. Chocolate Mint Creami

                        This one feels like a healthier version of mint chocolate chip ice cream. Mixing chocolate protein powder with a drop of peppermint extract creates that refreshing flavor combo, and the Creami gives it a rich texture. It’s the perfect dessert for mint lovers. 

                        12. Almond Mocha Treat

                          Think of this as a frozen version of a café mocha. Coffee, chocolate protein powder and a splash of almond extract blend into a tasty, energizing dessert that feels indulgent and balanced. It’s ideal for a little afternoon treat.

                          13. Cinnamon Roll Dessert

                            A cozy, dessert-for-breakfast kind of recipe. Vanilla protein powder mixed with a dash of cinnamon, maple syrup, vanilla essence and a spoonful of Greek yogurt creates a creamy, sweet base. It tastes just like the inside of a cinnamon roll — warm, spiced and buttery. 

                            14. Apple Pie Creami

                              This recipe is perfect for fall and tastes just like apple pie filling, only colder and creamier. Blend unsweetened applesauce with vanilla protein powder, a little cinnamon and nutmeg. The Ninja Creami turns it into a light, spiced ice cream that’s comforting and nostalgic — especially with a sprinkle of crushed graham cracker on top. 

                              How to Customize Your Ninja Creami Recipes

                              A few small tweaks can take your Creami creations to the next level. Here are some ideas and tips to make your frozen desserts even better:

                              • Use different milks such as almond, oat, macadamia or coconut for dairy-free versions.
                              • Adjust sweetness with honey, agave, maple syrup or sugar-free alternatives.
                              • Add fruit purees or extracts for new flavors without extra calories.
                              • Layer flavors in the pint before freezing to create natural swirls.
                              • Let your base freeze for at least 24 hours for the best texture.
                              • After spinning, if the mixture looks crumbly, re-spin with a splash of liquid for creamier results.
                              • Add mix-ins like crushed cookies, cereal, nuts, chocolate chips, pretzels, marshmallows or fruit after spinning to keep them crunchy. 
                              • Store leftovers in the freezer and re-spin when you’re ready to eat again. It revives the texture perfectly. 

                              The Ultimate Healthy Sweet Treat

                              These Ninja Creami recipes prove that healthy eating doesn’t have to mean boring food. With a little creativity, you can turn simple ingredients into protein-packed ice creams, fruity sorbets or creamy coffee desserts that taste like they came from your favorite cafe. These recipes are so good, you could even have them for breakfast. 

                              Previous ArticleThese 8 Spray Deodorants For Women Pass the Ultimate Stress Test Next ArticleBeyond the Gut: Why the Vaginal Microbiome Is the Next Big Thing in Women's Health
                              Subscribe CTA Image

                              Subscribers get even more tailored tips & deets delivered directly to their inboxes!